“Like Apartheid.” Maasai in Ngorongoro Conservation Area protest against forced evictions and loss of basic rights

The government has removed the Ngorongoro division from the voters’ register, denying the Maasai the right to vote.

The Maasai Indigenous People living in the Ngorongoro Conservation Area in Tanzania are facing a new round of violence and eviction from their homes. In January 2024, the government announced that will change the legal status of the Ngorongoro Conservation Area to prevent human settlement inside the protected area. About 100,000 people, nearly all Maasai pastoralists, would be forcibly evicted as a result.

In August 2024, the government removed the Ngorongoro division from the voters’ register thus denying Maasai pastoralists their right to vote. Ezeiel Omelangi, a Maasai activist from Ngorongoro accused the government of deliberately denying essential services from the Maasai. Healthcare and education services as well as water supply have been cut, and now the right to vote has been removed.

“This is a clear violation of our right to vote,” Omelangi told Down to Earth. “Our way of life and our very freedom are under attack.”

Onesmo Olengurumwa is the National Coordinator of the Tanzania Human Rights Defenders Coalition. He told Down to Earth that nearly half the population of Ngorongoro has been left out of the voters’ register. “Denying these people the right to vote means the the entire district cannot choose leaders of their choice,” Olengurumwa said. “It is time to end this systemic discrimination against the Maasai people.”

“Like Apartheid”

On 18 August 2024, thousands of Maasai blocked the road to the Ngorongoro Conservation Area in protest against the forced evictions and loss of basic rights. 16 people were arrested but subsequently released.

One of the banners held by the Maasai read, “We are required to move with pass cards in our own land. Like Apartheid SA.”

Joseph Oleshangay, a human rights lawyer, told Down to Earth,

“It may not be white against black as in Apartheid South Africa. But we feel like we are living in a Bantustan. . . .

“It is just like South Africa now for the Maasai. Their healthcare has been cut. If they want to go to the nearest health centre in the surrounding districts, they must carry their pass. Else the authorities will never allow them back in.”

Maasai community members have accused park rangers and security forces of “intimidation and rights abuses, including killings, sexual assaults and livestock seizures”, Al Jazeera reports.

The protest was organised to raise awareness about the human rights abuses that the Maasai communities in Ngorongoro are facing, including the threat of eviction from their homes.

Yet in a bizarre statement issued on 18 August 2024, the Ngorongoro Conservation Area Authority states that,

The demonstrations, widely reported on social media platforms, should serve as clear evidence to the international community and the media that there are no human rights violations or mistreatment of residents with the NCA.

The protests against conservation related human rights abuses in Tanzania are having some effect. In June 2024, the EU stopped funding for a conservation project in Tanzania. The US$20 million conservation project was initially meant for Tanzania and Kenya. Ana Pisonero Hernandez, an EU spokeswoman, told Al Jazeera that,

“The decision to amend the call was made to ensure the project’s objectives in terms of human rights protection and environmental concerns are achieved given recent tensions in the region.”

In 2023, the government of Tanzania denied three Members of European Parliament entry to the country who wanted to investigate the human rights abuses against the Maasai.

And in April 2024, the World Bank suspended funding for its Resilient Natural Resource Management for Tourism and Growth (REGROW). This US$150 million project is supposed to improve management of natural resources and tourism assets in Southern Tanzania, including the Ruaha National Park. But widespread human rights abuses were taking place against communities living near the park.

Two villagers, with support from the Oakland Institute, filed a complaint with the Bank’s Inspection Panel, which led to the suspension of funding.

Support for the Maasai from the Catholic church

Bishop Wofgang Pisa, the President of the Tanzania Episcopal Conference, urged the government “to respect the basis of good governance, transparency, truth, peace, and justice,” Vatican News reports. Bishop Pisa said,

“For what is happening in Ngorongoro, we ask the government ot return to the table and talk with the people of Ngorongoro, listen to them, and do not force them to relocate, or deny them essential social services, or block food from reaching them. Also, they should be given the right to vote where they currently reside. Today, you cannot tell the Tanzanian public that the Maasai are relocating voluntarily and then tomorrow we see Maasai on the streets crying and claiming their rights are being taken away.”

Further support for the Maasai came from the Maasai International Solidarity Alliance (MISA) who put out a statement on 19 August 2024. The statement is posted here in full:

Maasai International Solidarity Alliance (MISA) supports the Ngorongoro movement

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE -- 19 August 2024

The Maasai International Solidarity Alliance (MISA) stands in full solidarity with the Maasai of Ngorongoro who have bravely blocked the Ngorongoro-Serengeti road on Sunday 18 August 2024. Thousands of protesters demonstrated peacefully, sharing their plight with the world: “We are evicted so rich people change our homes into hotels”, “We are experiencing apartheid practices from Tanzanian government”, “It is sad to witness women suffering of oppression led by a woman President” or “Prisoners vote but Maasai of Ngorongoro not allowed to register as voters”. MISA is deeply impressed with the courage, determination and unity of the Ngorongoro Maasai, and fully supports their demands. It is high time their right to live and stay on the land is recognised, and their human rights as Tanzanian citizens are respected.

MISA calls on the Tanzanian President to:

• Immediately initiate a dialogue process with legitimate and elected Maasai leaders;

• Respect the right to peaceful demonstration and refrain from any form of violence;

• Uphold the right of all Tanzanian citizens, including the people of Ngorongoro, to vote and select their elected representatives by allowing them to participate in the ongoing voters’ registration;

• Restore all social services that have been blocked for almost three years, to respect and fulfil the human rights to food, education and health;

• Put an end to any attempt to displace the Maasai from Ngorongoro Conservation Area (NCA);

• Develop a sustainable strategy to address the acute food insecurity and humanitarian crisis in NCA, including lifting the ban on subsistence farming, ensuring full access to grazing areas and supporting pastoralism as a viable and resilient livelihood;

• Ensure full participation of the people living in NCA in the management of the area and obtain free, prior and informed consent (FPIC) for any decision impacting their lives and livelihoods;

• Ensure local communities substantially benefit from tourism operations in NCA including through benefit-sharing, decent employment and participatory management of tourism activities to ensure tourism levels remain sustainable;

• Stop all forms of anti-Maasai discrimination, confiscation of livestock and the alienation of land across all Maasai districts.

Recognising the historical and shared responsibilities of the European Union and its Member States (including Germany), the United Kingdom and the United States in the current crisis, MISA calls on the international community to:

• Openly condemn the decision to deny the Maasai of Ngorongoro the right to vote; donors funding good governance and the democratisation of Tanzania should insist that the rights of Maasai must be respected like those of any other Tanzanian citizen;

• Address the current food security crisis in NCA, including by making funding available for pro-pastoralist programmes to advance people’s right to feed themselves, and by providing urgent humanitarian assistance;

• Stop funding conservation projects that separate humans from nature and lead to the displacement of Indigenous Peoples from their lands; Frankfurt Zoological Society (FZS) should immediately stop all its activities in Maasai land, especially in Loliondo where it is complicit in the grabbing of land (Pololet).

Noting that Ngorongoro was recognised as Natural World Heritage in 1979, Biosphere Reserve in 1981, Cultural World Heritage in 2010 and as Ngorongoro-Lengai Global Geopark in 2018, MISA calls on UNESCO, the World Heritage Committee (WHC) and advisory bodies ICOMOS and IUCN to:

• Recognise that its recommendations have, over the last 20 years, had a negative impact on the human rights of people in NCA, including their right to food, by encouraging a cultivation ban and prohibiting access to essential grazing areas such as the Ngorongoro, Olromti and Embakaai craters; all these restrictions should be lifted;

• Stop facilitating the displacement of Maasai from NCA including by recommending that incentives be set up to relocate people;

• Recognise that Maasai people, their culture and pastoralist practices are contributing to the integrity and conservation of the site and should be protected;

• Condemn the removal of social services in NCA and demand that people’s right to education, health and housing be respected;

• Review the nomination status of NCA in light of the fact that Indigenous Peoples have the right to FPIC and that Maasai were never consulted;

• Condemn the lack of involvement, participation and consultation of the Maasai in the management of the World Heritage Site, which is contrary to UNESCO rules of procedures, and demand immediate action to ensure co-management by Indigenous Peoples;

• Ensure full participation, involvement and consent of the Maasai in UNESCO and WHC decision-making processes including reactive missions and all decisions about Ngorongoro.

For any media inquiries, please contact:

Joseph Oleshangay, Human Rights Lawyer: joseshangay [a] gmail . com; Mobile +255769637623

The Maasai International Solidarity Alliance (MISA) is an international alliance standing in solidarity with the Maasai of Northern Tanzania. We bring together international faith-based organisations, human rights organisations, international aid and development organisations, as well as grassroots organisations, individual activists, researchers and lawyers representing the Maasai in several land cases. Our alliance includes, among others, the Africa Europe Faith Justice Network (AEFJN), Agrecol Association for AgriCulture & Ecology, Coalition of European Lobbies for Eastern African Pastoralism (CELEP), CIDSE - International family of Catholic social justice organisations (International), Indigenous Movement for Peace Advancement and Conflict Transformation (IMPACT), FIAN International, FINAL GOVERNANCE, KOO - Koordinierungsstelle der Österreichischen Bischofskonferenz (Coordinating Office of the Austrian Bishops' Conference), Gesellschaft für bedrohte Völker (Society for Threatened Peoples), Misereor, PINGO’s Forum (Pastoralists Indigenous Non-Governmental Organisations), PWC (Pastoral Women’s Council), TEST (Traditional Ecosystems Survival Tanzania), UCRT (Ujamaa Community Resource Team) and Welthaus Graz. Our main objective is to put an end to the human rights violations facing the Maasai of northern Tanzania.

---