PHOTO Credit: “Wildlife Works out of Ka'apor territory! The carbon market is a false environmental solution!”
US-based REDD project developer Wildlife Works, together with Forest Trends, is proposing a REDD project in the Alto Turiaçu Indigenous Territory in the State of Maranhão, Brazil. But many of the Ka’apor Indigenous People who live there are opposed to having a carbon trading project in their territory.
Thanks for reading REDD-Monitor! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
The Ka’apor people have called on Brazilian federal prosecutors to evict Wildlife Works from their territory. The Ka’apor complain that the company’s operations are unwelcome and are generating conflict in the Indigenous community.
On 31 January 2024, the Ka’apor sent a letter to the executive director of Wildlife Works in Brazil, demanding that the company immediately withdraws from their territory and ceases all operations there.
In December 2023, REDD-Monitor wrote about the opposition to this REDD project, following reporting by The Intercept.
In July 2024, the Ka’apor people hosted a meeting where they discussed the threats to their territory, including oil exploration, mining, hydropower dams, agribusiness, and REDD.
Letter of Indigenous Peoples, peasants, traditional communities and Afro-descendants in Latin America
In the Indigenous territory of Alto Turiaçu, in the Aldeia Ararorenda of the Ka’apor people, in the state of Maranhão, Brazil, from the 9th to the 11th of July, we held our first meeting as indigenous peoples, peasants, traditional communities, quilombolas (descendants of escaped slaves), organizations defending Indigenous rights from different countries in the Pan-Amazon region and Central American territories, where projects known as REDD+ (Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation) have arrived. To make it easier, when we refer to REDD below, we are also including other names created using the same logic as REDD (for example, when talking about forest carbon projects, nature-based solutions, or jurisdictional REDD programs implemented by state or provincial governments and national governments, among others).
After three days of sharing experiences and analyzing what REDD+ really means for our peoples and territories, we concluded that we are facing two projects: one is the death project that oil, mining, hydroelectric and large infrastructure companies, agribusiness, and now compensation projects such as REDD, together with nation-states, promote, and second, a life project that is carried forward by our peoples and communities through respect and care for our territories.
In view of this, we issue the following statement, so that our brothers and sisters from different peoples and communities do not fall into this trap:
REDD’s death project
1. Breaks the unity and harmony of our people and generates conflicts, including within our own families.
2. Threatens the lives of women, children, and the elderly, by depriving us of the subsistence we have in our forests for food and access to water.
3. Criminalizes the livelihoods of our people and communities.
4. Manipulates our leaders into signing contracts without the consent of our people.
5. Seeks greater economic benefits for its businesses and encourages deforestation, because the more deforestation there is, the more business for companies that sell carbon credits.
6. Take control of our territories and take away our autonomy.
7. Like other false solutions to the climate catastrophe, called “unconventional oil exploration,” “biofuels,” “responsible mining,” or “green gold,” “energy transition,” it is greenwashing that allows companies to continue their business and polluting.
Furthermore:
8. Compensation mechanisms, such as REDD, allow companies to continue polluting and do not reduce emissions.
9. REDD promotes the creation of protected areas, depriving us of livelihoods and banning us from our territories.
10. We reject the 30x30 goals that seek to achieve conservation affecting our territories while protecting the interests of large companies.
11. Governments violate Constitutions and change laws that protect our territories to facilitate and favor extractive companies and REDD-type projects.
REDD projects are projects of death, because instead of protecting, they are destroying nature and our people.
In our life project
1. We defend our territories, our rivers, forests, sacred sites, spirits with whom we interact so that they can live and so that we can live, our ancestral knowledge and culture, our medicinal plants, materials for our homes, for crafts that we use for our subsistence, our food.
2. We demand and fight for the titling and demarcation of territories.
3. We recognize and respect the rights of nature in harmony with people.
4. We defend self-government, self-determination and autonomy of peoples.
5. We defend and respect our ways of life, which are those that guarantee the defense and care of our territories.
6. We demand the implementation of the fundamental right to consultation and free, prior and informed consent, respecting the right of veto, considering ILO Convention 169 and the various agreements and declarations of international law.
7. We recognize and respect traditional knowledge as a fundamental condition of life.
8. We respect and fight for health and education in our languages and cultures.
9. We fight for territories of peace, free from companies and government policies that pollute and destroy.
10. We advocate and work to create opportunities for our young people based on our knowledge and wisdom.
11. Our territories have no economic value. They are financially invaluable.
12. We emphasize the central role of women in defending our territories.
13. We urge human rights organizations to speak out and defend respect for the territorial rights of our peoples.
They have been killing us since colonization began more than five centuries ago. Currently, oil, mining, agribusiness, hydroelectric and other infrastructure projects and carbon offset projects, such as REDD, together with State policies, continue the ethnocide of our people, killing our cultures, languages, identities , knowledge, and wisdom.
ENOUGH! NO to REDD!
Translation by Forrest Hylton.
Thanks for reading REDD-Monitor! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
Really great that the people stand up to corporate death. Yes, it is a form of colonialism, perhaps the final act, where a bit of forest is tied up permanently so that a small unit of emissions can happen now. Or, for the corrupt 30x30 plan, a bit of forest is tied up permanently so that a Corporation can feel right about destroying one more greenfield. But item 11 is a problem: "Our territories have no economic value. They are financially invaluable." A North American Indigenous concept is "We cannot sell the Earth, our Mother." The territories DO have economic value, to the Capitalist, who endeavors to monetize them for his profit, of course. Then strip any salable resource (in this case being totally imaginary "offsets") or timber, or oil and gas, then leave it in ruins. The Statement should be: "Our territories are priceless!" The neoliberal goal is to monetize all of Nature and of course enable that monetary value to flow to the most wealthy. And for everyone else, "Let them eat cake."
Really great that the people stand up to corporate death. Yes, it is a form of colonialism, perhaps the final act, where a bit of forest is tied up permanently so that a small unit of emissions can happen now. Or, for the corrupt 30x30 plan, a bit of forest is tied up permanently so that a Corporation can feel right about destroying one more greenfield. But item 11 is a problem: "Our territories have no economic value. They are financially invaluable." A North American Indigenous concept is "We cannot sell the Earth, our Mother." The territories DO have economic value, to the Capitalist, who endeavors to monetize them for his profit, of course. Then strip any salable resource (in this case being totally imaginary "offsets") or timber, or oil and gas, then leave it in ruins. The Statement should be: "Our territories are priceless!" The neoliberal goal is to monetize all of Nature and of course enable that monetary value to flow to the most wealthy. And for everyone else, "Let them eat cake."